Desktop Forums Blog Support Patreon
Official Steam Group | Patreon Chat
jack1974
For info and pre-purchase links:

http://winterwolves.com/heirsandgraces.htm



Download the beta version here:

http://www.macgames.biz/games/HeirsAndGraces-0.8.5-all.zip

(like all betas, there's no installer, just a .zip file to unzip and play)



What's New in 0.8.5

- jealousy scenes now trigger after the 4th scene of each character playthrough

- writer slightly modified some jealousy scenes so they work better since they happen early in the story

- removed the cheat to display the skillcheck count since it's no longer needed

- fixed more typos/sentences



What's New in 0.8.4

- Kamal & Borges jealousy was broken (would repeat forever) so fixed that scene only (the others were OK!)



What's New in 0.8.3

- fixed the endlessly jealousy scenes (AKA "forever jealous"!). Now they correctly play once, and force you to choose between one of the two characters :)



What's New in 0.8.2

- fixed jealousy scenes triggering: now they trigger after the second scene of each route, not based on relationship percentage, to avoid weird situations later in the story where Marcel seems mad :lol:

- lowered the amount of skillchecks needed to trigger the skillful achievement to 14: since it should only count the main plot checks, and not the romance bonus CG one. Also removed the reputation double check at the end, it only checks once.

- fixed a lot of typos! and replaced the "Yeah" with other words/sentences. Marcel's hair will also be left in peace :lol:

- the ending happy romance ending scenes won't trigger if you have Reputation less than 90 and leave with Licia :)

- added a "cheat": press key C to display the amount of main plot checks passed. Useful to test for those who don't manage to get the "Skillful" achievement. The value to unlock the achievement at end of the story (after last Reputation check) should be 14.



What's New in 0.8.1

- Vincent's second scene will play only after Eloy is introduced

- Borges' third scene will play only after Licia is introduced

- Kamal and Eloy sexy bonus CG should now play!

- made Easy mode a bit more easy too. But in general following the walkthrough you should be able to win even in Normal difficulty!

- fixed some wrong Marcel sudden outfit changes (if you find more let me know!)

- fixed various typos



Difficulty should be fine: in Normal you need to figure out how to distribute the points in the early weeks to have enough reputation at the end. I tried and it's definitely doable. In Easy mode, you should reall try hard to lose :lol:



In any case, as always here's a walkthrough. But if you like to find your way to win I won't recommend reading it immediately! :wink:


To win this game and unlock the final "happy" romance ending, you need to have enough relationship with the love interest (obviously) but also enough reputation at the end of the game.

The relationship needed is 100%, while the reputation needed is 90, and you must reach both values within week 34 (the last week of the story).

During the game there are various skill checks that will raise or lower the reputation by 5. The key to win is to pass the early check of the story since they will all give you 5 points.

The good news is that the reputation also increases (albeit slowly) with the random outcomes of the game activities, so you don't need to pass ALL the skill checks to win (though there's an achievement for that!).



Below there's the various skill checks in the order they appear in the game:

1) Tidiness & Strength >= 10. So for the first two week, do Clean Rooms and Haul Luggage to reach the required values.

2) Etiquette & Management >=10. In the 3rd and 4th week, do Write Letters and Take Inventory to reach again the required values.

3) Now things get slightly harder: in this check you need 20 Strength and 10 Awareness. In week from 5 to 7 do Attend Guest and Haul Luggage and you will have enough values.

4) next check is easier: Diligence & Education >=10. In weeks from 8 to 10 do Gardening and Shelve Books and you should have the right values.

5) the scene 10 of main plot is the key scene since there are 3 checks! you need Charisma 10 and Diligence & Tidiness at 20. Because of that in weeks from 11 to 14 you should use Gardening, Charm Shopkeeper and Clean Rooms. You should be able to reach the required values without problems.



At this point you are about halfway through the game. You should have already some relationships if you picked the right answers. Some (or in some cases all, especially if you're playing in Easy mode) of next checks can be failed, since you'll still have enough reputation from the scheduler. Here they are:

6) scene 11: Education & Management >=20

7) scene 13: Charisma & Awareness >=20

8) scene 14: Etiquette >=20



The best strategy for weeks until week 20 is to do 1-2 days of an activity that might raise the value of the remaining checks, and the other 5-6 days do the 2 activities related to the character you're pursuing. This way you'll advance in the related stat and increase the relationship.



The 9th scene with each character has a special CG event, which requires a value of 90 in the related stat. For example you'll need 90 in Physique to see a sweating shirtless Kamal :) You can still get the final romance even if you miss those bonus CG scenes though.



From the week 20 onward, you should focus on the two activities related to the love interest. For Kamal for example would be Haul Luggage & Gardening. Keep doing those two, and eventually you'll max one of the two values: when a value is maxed, it will ALWAYS give Reputation or Relationship! Which means that once you reach Diligence 100, every time you do Gardening again will increase Kamal relationship by 1. Or once you reach Strength 100, every time you do Haul Luggage your Reputation will increase by 1.



If you keep this in mind, in the last weeks of the game you should get a boost either in relationship or reputation that will let you win the game and unlock the ending CGs!

SimonStardust
I actually found time to give the game a short try today and... I'm so impressed. :D

Writing, art and music work great together and I'm a huge fan of how the story progresses. The characters are written so lively it makes the whole game exciting and funny enough to read even when one doesn't plan on romancing any of the guys. (I for one do of course. xD Thought of going for either Vincent or Kamal for a first try. ^^)

That short first impression and praise given... I'll call it quits for today and then maybe will start tomorrow taking down notes on some spelling mistakes I came across. (I'm too good for my own tastes at finding those. x,D)


Yeah... on my first try... I got the bad ending. Just my luck, I guess. xDDD

jack1974
Haha well the first weeks is essential to pass the skill checks, otherwise you get a bad ending. Past that, things get easier :)

(if you follow the walkthrough you can't miss it)
fabulaparva
Love the game so far! Got to the end of the demo last night. Purchased the full game, too, but due to upcoming Mother's Day weekend, I'm afraid I won't have much time to go further until next week. Can't wait! I saw that Kamal and Rene got the prettiest backgrounds in the wallpapers. <3 :mrgreen:



Question: Whenever we are making response choices, is the positive/successful choice always worth half a rose? I think I saw the bar go up a whole rose at one point with Borges. I'll try to find that that again later if that's not how it's supposed to be.
jack1974
The first 5 scenes, they go up half rose (or 5%) while in the last 5 scenes, they go up for a "full rose" (10%). I did that because otherwise was too hard to reach 100% at the end, at least in Normal difficulty :)
ChaosMorning
Okay, so I purchased and played through the game because I've been dying for a BL/yaoi only game from you, and have thus been following Heirs & Graces quite avidly.



Since my university degree (in creative writing) is largely not terribly fulfilling in terms of what I can use it for, I'm going to do a little review on the story, because workshopping other people's writing is literally one of my few skills.



There are a few problems, grammatically I found a few little issues (early in the game there is a use of 'too' where it should be 'to'). Small but it was jarring for me as I was reading.



There was a distinct overuse of the word Yeah throughout the game. Especially by characters who I expected to be refined enough to say, I don't know, Yes, Of Course, Perhaps, It would seem so, Indeed or anything else (Vincent, Sandor, etc). It got to be a bit annoying, especially during the final few scenes.



Also, why does it seem everyone has the same way of expressing affection for Marcel? You can only ruffle someone's hair so many times. I mean, for Kamal, who did it the most, it made sense. But should Eloy perhaps not do something more teasing? Or what's wrong with a squeeze of the shoulder or hand? It just really stuck out to me.



I played through most of the routes simultaneously, and I believe each feels relatively distinct. They all did certainly play into their particular tropes, but in ways I found enjoyable. Yes, Eloy is a flirt and falls into those cliches, but seeing the interactions between him and Sandor were wonderful, and the writer touched upon the lifespan issues for he and Marcel in a way that I found both touching and saddening. I applaud that. Borges was refreshing, and the subplot both romantic and comedic enough that I rather enjoyed it thoroughly. Kamal was



Vincent, whom I went in expecting to really pursue, ended up seeming somewhat dull in comparison. I played through eight of his events before a jealousy scene triggered, and I decided to drop him. Hopefully when I do decide to follow through with his route, I will find something more in him.



One of my favourite scenes? Where Rosalynn and Marcel have their argument, and she's moving his head about with her heel. Wow. Great character defining moment. I loved it.



Now, the relationship between Marcel and Sandor? Damn. I don't cry easily - and no, this game did not make me cry, but I did feel the sensation of sympathy and sadness, and had a little stinging in my eyes. And for a stone cold bitch like me, that means something.



I will say though, I played through the Good Alone ending, and it was... not satisfying, perhaps because it seemed to end a bit abruptly. Maybe there are ways in which Rosalynn is dealt with and other issues (like Licia's family and her decision about revenge) that are settled in other routes, but nothing seemed very well addressed here. As it is a dating sim perhaps this should be expected.



On the technically side, multiple times throughout the game Marcel changed outfit mid conversation. It would happen for one line of dialogue and then he would switch back. Other times it seemed as though he was wearing his regular outfit when he should have been dressed in his uniform.



Next, the scene introducing Licia and Renee triggered after one of Borges' in which Licia and Marcel were shopping. It was confusing, and I expect that it is probably meant to trigger after the scene in which I learn Licia's name, not before.



Lastly on the technical, and this is a gameplay issue, wow - 90 points on Easy mode for the bachelor's requirements? Yikes. I was at about 40 in all of the groups (Decorum, Physique, etc) and in the mid 40s with the individual stats (Etiquette, Tidiness, etc) by the time Eloy and Borges' scenes requiring me to have 90 Decorum and Knowledge respectively triggered. Perhaps on Easy Mode 90 should be lowered to 45 or 50? At least one of those I can manage on easy, because I was trying to keep all the stats up to meet the requirements in the main events and grab that achievement.



Alright, so that's that. I think I'll wait to replay and get the bachelor's endings for when version 1 or further have been officially released, so things get the chance to be spruced up and balanced and whatnot. I was just to eager to play this, and I really loved my first playthrough.
Foelhe
Lastly on the technical, and this is a gameplay issue, wow - 90 points on Easy mode for the bachelor's requirements? Yikes. I was at about 40 in all of the groups (Decorum, Physique, etc) and in the mid 40s with the individual stats (Etiquette, Tidiness, etc) by the time Eloy and Borges' scenes requiring me to have 90 Decorum and Knowledge respectively triggered. Perhaps on Easy Mode 90 should be lowered to 45 or 50? At least one of those I can manage on easy, because I was trying to keep all the stats up to meet the requirements in the main events and grab that achievement.


I agree with you on most of what you said, but I think the right strategy here is to get everything up to twenty, then completely ignore all the stats that aren't tied to your chosen bachelor. That means you'll only see one or maybe two of those CGs in a given playthrough, but it makes reaching 90 on that one pretty simple.



On a related note, I should have gotten Kamal's bonus CG, but the game pulled a file-not-found and didn't pull it up. Not sure if that's an error or if the beta just hasn't had those added yet. Thought I'd mention.
Exizel

On a related note, I should have gotten Kamal's bonus CG, but the game pulled a file-not-found and didn't pull it up. Not sure if that's an error or if the beta just hasn't had those added yet. Thought I'd mention.


I got the problem too.



And it's not really bug but I saw the scene with Marcel and Licia following Rene and Borges two day before the scene where Licia introduce herself to Marcel.
jack1974
Thanks for feedback, regarding the problems: Kamal CG should show up, but I think I know what's the issue. I think also Eloy CG won't work, so will do an update later today or tomorrow, also fixing some of those "this scene should play after this one" thing :)



About the stats values needed: if you read the walkthrough it's clearly explained how it works (I'll also make a separate thread since I think some people miss it). Lowering the requirements to 40-50... well, would make the game super easy and the whole stat raising pointless :wink:. You only need to reach 20 in all skills, and that is not even required, unless you want to unlock the related achievement.
jack1974
Just updated the game to 0.8.1 fixing some issues. Of course let me know if you find something else :) thanks
ChaosMorning
Okay, so I got decorum related scene and it worked fine, but Eloy's romantic scene still doesn't trigger.
jack1974
You mean the final scene? do you have 100% relationship with him and Reputation >=90 ?
ChaosMorning
I think so? I had 101 Reputation and triggered 10 scenes for him. I'll see about raising his meter - maybe I didn't get 100% or something?
jack1974
Yes I think so, since I tested all the final endings, so I think should work. In the last stages if you do the activity that raises relationship you should get to 100% faster :)
SimonStardust
Right now I'm more or less halfway through the game and I think it's time for me to report some typos and other mistakes I found. Can't say much about grammar though, because I'm no native speaker.




General things first I guess:



While I grew really attached to Kamal ruffling Marcel's hair once and awhile I found it not quite fitting for Eloy to do so. Maybe because I found it to be... well... simply a Kamal-thing. XD Same goes for other gestures like striking the chin while thinking. Some characters may do this, others will show that they are thinking otherwise. Well... maybe it's just me being a bit nitpicky, but in my opinion gestures should be part of personality, too. Especially when they are repeated that noticeably often.

Quite similar it stroke me when Borges said »yeah« when he also just could have said »yes« or sth similar. While the word didn't disturb me when used by Marcel or Kamal, I found it not to be fitting for Borges' personality. But again – it's only my opinion. Others my be just fine with it the way it is.



Well, now on to the more specific mistakes I found so far:



- I found several colons followed by a lower case letter. I'm not quite sure if English language has its own rules for the use of colons, but usually they should be followed by an upper case letter. (I'm sorry for not quoting the exact sentences here – I found way too many and decided to treat it as a single subitem.)



- In the scene where Borges is first introduced... it displays his name although we don't even know it yet. Should be »???« instead during half of the scene.



- Same scene as above:

»It echos in my brain and an unreal floating sensation flows through my body.«


echos → echoes



- When Marcel comes to Lord Sandor's aid while he has his coughing fit, Marcel is still displayed with the bread and water in his hands. Found it to be a little bit odd.



- The scene where Marcel and Kamal are searching for information on flowers in the library:

»Kamal stays put and we look at them together instead of seperately.«

seperately → separately

»That's undisputed King of Aarvorn, Marcel the highly esteemed to you.«


Aarvorn → Aravorn (obviously xD)



- The scene where Vincent and Borges are having their dispute:

»Without a named heir its impossible to know what will happen to his job when Lord Sandor does die.«


its → it's



- Dining scene with Lord Sandor and Eloy:

»Vincent starts going over what I'll have to do a server.«

Don't really know if I just lack knowledge on the English language or if this is indeed a mistake, but I think it should be »to do as a server.«



- Second scene where Marcel visits Lord Sandor in his room:

»That's probaby a good thing.«

probaby → probably

»It takes a bit of manuvering, but I manage to open the door.«

manuvering → maneuvering



- Scene with Eloy in the library:

»You can't tell me you that if I offered you a choice between two books of different genres you'd just pick randomly.«

Just »You can't tell me that if I...« without the second »you.«



- Scene with Eloy and the broken vase:

»His face is mere inches away from mine now and for the first time I start to wonder if I should really be doing ths.«

ths → this



- When Marcel asks Borges about the things he read in that medicine book:

»If I have a choice, I'd rather him not be dead I guess.«

Again I'm not sure if it's possible to phrase it that way, but I'd say there is a verb like »have«missing. The correct sentence being: »..., I'd rather have him not be dead.«

»I admire your enthusiasm but, If it's alright with you, I'd prefer it if we did this one question at a time.«

If → if



- At the market when Marcel and Licia detect Borges and Rene meeting, Licia is stammering a couple of times. While it may not be a mistake per se, it sounds odd to me to stammer like this: »S-she«, »T-then.« More naturally I'd write: »Sh-she« and »Th-then.« But I guess it's personal taste.



- Same scene:

»It's pretty worn down and there are several bookmarks hidden away between it's pages.«

it's → its



- Kamal giving Marcel first lectures about fighting:

»So, I guess what I'm saying is that you shouldn't rely soley on your skills as a warrior.«

soley → solely

Also... »environment« was written a few times as »enviorment« during this scene.



- Eloy talking about Grandtree with Marcel:

»From his description I mainly get a sense of lonliness.«

lonliness → loneliness



- When Borges treats Lord Sandor with the naga potion:

»I know I shouldn't care, but I'm wondering what exactly is so bad about me being Borges' assitant.«

assitant → assistant

»The potions effects last for another thirty minutes or so before Lord Sandor is finally able to rest.«

potions → potion's



- Marcel teaching Vincent how to cook potato soup:

»I probably should have taken an extra minute to take care of my appearence.«

appearence → appearance

»...Its no good then?«

Its → It's



- When Licia and Rene make up stories about Marcel's ring:

»Maybe Vincent hired Marcel to assasinate a troublesome noble that was bothering Lord Sandor!«

assasinate → assassinate

»What is important is that you took the time to pick something out for specifically for me.«


One »for« will do in this sentence. ^^

»You could have just picked up a random book and I would have liked it, but it honestly it wouldn't have been that memorable.«

Same thing. One »it« after the »but« is enough. ^^



- Kamal telling Marcel about his past in the Dingirra arena:

»I decided that I needed to see what I could learn from the fighters in the Dingirra before I went looking for my rematch.«

After »Dingirra« there should be an »arena« I guess. Or cancel the »the« in front of »Dingirra.«

»Because that wasn't going to well for you earlier.«

to → too



- Tea scene with Lady Rosalynn and Eloy in the garden:

»If there is one thing I like about Lady Rosalynn, it's her ability to drive out guests intent on overstaying their welcome.«

Not quite sure (found the sentence to be difficult), but I think »guests« should be »guests'« instead.

»In fact, I'm fairly certain they've told everyone that I'm attempting a century journey to give the appearence that I'm actually doing something worthwhile with my time.«

appearence → appearance

»Lord Shiraan crosses his arms, trying not to look to displeased.«

to → too

»For someone who just slung blatant insults, she seems awfully surprised that Lord Shiraan returning the favor.«


I guess »...awfully surprised that Lord Shiraan is returning the favor« would be more correct.

»For instance, I seem to recall hearing how insitant your family was in pressuring Lord Sandor to abandon the woman he loved when she was pregnant with his child.«

insitant → insistent



- When Vincent is visiting ill Marcel:

»Vincent tired expression darkens a bit as if he's reimagining several horrors.«

Vincent → Vincent's

»I did burn my toungue a little.«

toungue → tongue

»Of course, you didn't seem to eager to get up early the last time I got you up to cook something.«

to → too

»Of course, when i said every once and awhile, I meant it.«

i → I



- Preparations for the servants' party:

»I'm sure you're a natural.«

I don't exactly know what Licia meant to say with that sentence. Either it's a way to refer to what she said earlier or there is simply a word missing.



Well... that's it for now. Will be back when I have found more typos. Trying not to miss a single one. xD

jack1974
Thanks for the feedback. I'll check typos, about the grammar/English stuff I'll let the writer decide what to do (I surely can't judge myself if it's correct or not! :lol:)
SilverHyena
Thanks for all the feedback guys! It's super helpful.



And Jack, all of SimonStardust's corrections are fine. A few of the grammar suggestions work either way so it's fine to just switch them over to Simon's suggestions. (And oh my gosh, sorry for so many typos and misspellings... I know they're bound to happen, but still... :shock: Thanks for catching them, SimonStardust!)



I have work later today, but after that I have the next two days off so I'll look into the other stuff. I'll definitely look over the gesture thing. I did actually mean to make the ruffling hair thing a Kamal exclusive. I'll see what alternatives I can find for the other characters. I'll also look into the yeah thing. I didn't realize I had that tendency. :P If you guys have any specific examples where it's super jarring feel free to share them. It'd help me out.
fabulaparva
Finished my first playthrough where I tried to be a jack-of-all-trades, aka played everything without the walkthrough just to see where it'd get me. (30 and above on all skills, reputation 82 -- so I didn't get the good Reputation NOR the Bad Reputation achievement --I did get the Casanova badge, though!!! :P)



I see that SimonStardust caught most of the typos I saw, too. I don't have anything to add at this point to his list, but I'll keep my eyes open later. I agree with the hair-ruffling thing as I'm so tired of seeing everyone ruffling the heroine's heir in localized otome games --it's a miracle my japanese heroines are not bald already! I really would only have Kamal do that as it does fit him, but immediately feels overused if the others (eg Eloy) do it, too.



This is obviously more of a gameplay issue than actual story issue, but if you play as I did, doing a little bit of that and a little bit of this activity, you'll end up having Marcel to be someone who completely plays every love interest in the game while being absolutely unaware of it himself! Spoilers ensue...


I found this somewhat confusing as he is going into deep thoughts and possessing about Vincent's ring and then a few days later is considering running off to Borges to be his assistant and getting all upset about the charade with Borges' father and Rene. He also pranced through multiple kissing scenes towards the end (Kamal, Eloy & Vincent) and I was thoroughly weirded out how Marcel seemed to have no recollection in him how he had just been locking lips with someone else just a few days before...and with all the internal dialogue he had earlier seemingly forgotten as if had never existed. So basically I was at a point where Kamal had kissed Marcel, Marcel had kissed Eloy and Eloy had kissed Marcel and then Marcel kissed Vincent...and after all this there's a very downplayed and civil jealousy scene where Kamal asks Marcel how he feels about Vincent and him...but the whole Eloy-steaminess never gets addressed..



Gawddamn he EARNED that Casanova-badge!! :P :P



I'm not sure how this could be made to seem more realistic, so that Marcel wouldn't look like he has some sort of disassociation syndrome. Maybe the jealousy scenes might trigger earlier? It seemed as if the relationship scenes were more dependent on Marcel's skill stats and activities than on the actual relationship percentages, as Marcel's highest relationship was with Kamal 70-something% and only in the 40-50-something% with Vincent and Eloy and yet I got to scene number ten both with Vincent and Eloy.



Anyway, I haven't found any major bugs yet. Near the end there's a small graphical bug: when all the chars are lining up for goodbyes Kamal stays on the screen after the text tells that he backed off. I can send a savegame later if you need/want one?



More feedback coming later this week. :)
jack1974
Finished my first playthrough where I tried to be a jack-of-all-trades, aka played everything without the walkthrough just to see where it'd get me. (30 and above on all skills, reputation 82 -- so I didn't get the good Reputation NOR the Bad Reputation achievement --I did get the Casanova badge, though!!! :P)

Haha well the game shouldn't allow you to go much far trying to be jack-of-all-trades or romancing several characters.
I'm so tired of seeing everyone ruffling the heroine's heir in localized otome games --it's a miracle my japanese heroines are not bald already!

Haha I laughed hard reading this sentence! :lol:



Regarding your observations, I agree that is better to move the jealousy scenes sooner. I'll do that, since the routes weren't written as you could romance more than one people for too long :)



Edit: I think I know the issue, the jealousy were triggering based on the relationships: however as you played, you could have one at 70% and another at 45-50%, and still reach a high scene (like scene 8-9 or more). So on next update, I am triggering the relationships based on the scene number: after the third scene with each character, the jealousy will trigger. I think this way many of your end-game issues should be solved :)
Foelhe
Has anyone managed to get the Skillful achievement yet? I think I should have unlocked it on my last playthrough, but no dice. Then again, I might have just missed a check somewhere.