Desktop Forums Blog Support Patreon
Official Steam Group | Patreon Chat
jack1974
Haha, forgive the title, but... if I check the most recent hits on Steam, like:

- Sunless Sea

- Darkest Dungeon

or even the old ones like FTL or Dark Souls, they seem to have all in common one thing: they're INCREDIBLY difficult and unforgiving. Dying seems part of the story. Now personally I hate this so I never played them much. I liked FTL, but every time seems like I KNEW I was going to lose, so after a while I quit. Dark Souls was even worse for me, I got it as part of the Playstation plus subscription, played maybe 20-25 minutes then immediately uninstalled it. If I had paid even $1 for it I would have been angry.



Yet the market clearly wants more of those hard, unforgiving, frustrating games. I definitely am out of the loop :o
Taleweaver
Don't ever start playing Nethack, then :)
jack1974
Haha I played it but was years ago. I don't think has changed much though :)

Anyway, I think that those games have great setting/atmosphere, but probably aren't just my cup of tea. I would prefer something difficult but not THAT difficult :oops:
Franka
It's the nature of Roguelikes. They appeal to a certain kind of audience, both for their difficulty and for their procedurally generated content. I still remember getting to level 50 in Rogue, then being told, "You have to climb back out now." NOOOOOOOO
fleetp
Reminds me a bit of the first Witcher game.


If you failed to obtain spectre oil to rub on your sword, you could not defeat the first boss (helldog), with the added inconvenience of not being able to go back and get the oil. Even with the cream, defeating that first boss was very hard (I had to use a cheat to get higher power potions to get past him).



If I hadn't paid full retail for the game, I would have tossed it in the trash.
Alex81
Haha, forgive the title, but... if I check the most recent hits on Steam, like:

- Sunless Sea

- Darkest Dungeon

or even the old ones like FTL or Dark Souls, they seem to have all in common one thing: they're INCREDIBLY difficult and unforgiving. Dying seems part of the story. o


You mean , like Seasons of the Wolf? ^^



(:o I get eaten alive by the enemies there, and ...only 50 percent health/mana back after sleeping at home in Chapter one? That's your toughest game so far!



All that said? I didn't really that much trouble With Dark Souls, I quickly learned to jump out of harms way when enemies attacked, and luckily ,their attack patters weren't that hard to learn.
jack1974
Haha SOTW Nightmare difficulty is nothing compared to those new roguelikes... Darkest Dungeon & Co! :wink:
Harbinger1975
I think the toughest game for me (at the time) was Mechwarrior 2: Mercenaries. If you got caught not paying attention to your radar, your heat, your ammo and the damage to your Mech, and you got jumped by the Draconis Combine? Yeah, you were screwed. I can't tell you how many times it took me to try and beat one particular mission.
Sylrissa
I wish GoG would get a hold of Mechwarrior games, I'd enjoy playing through those again.



I still remember the time I completed a mission and my mech was busted up all to shit and I needed to get to the extraction point outside the city. so here I was slowly hoping on 1 leg with barely any systems left running for like the next 20mins to make it. Felt really good :D
jack1974
Yes I played those Mechwarrior games too, they were quite cool indeed :)
Harbinger1975
There use to be a place called MekTek.net that use to help keep the games playable on today's systems. But...I just went looking for them and they are pretty much only focused on the next Heavy Gear which looks to be an Arena game. No thanks. God I miss those old Mech games. And no, I don't consider Mechwarrior Online a true Mechwarrior game. I was sickened by the sell outs to make it a multiplayer deathmatch.
Jaeger
Well, the most common criticism in many games today is they are too easy, especially for those who grew up playing games from the 90s or older. Being more challenging than most games in recent years is where Demon Souls and its successors found their niche.
jack1974
I started playing games at end of 1980, but still nowadays I prefer easier games, or well balanced but it's hard. For example I'm playing DA:I in Normal difficulty and found it perfect for me, but in some other cases the "Normal" difficulty was just insane.

I played Demon Souls/Dark Souls (don't remember which one) for about 10 minutes and then quit it! :lol: I got it free with PS+, otherwise I would have been angry to have paid for it, because for me it's zero fun, though of course I understand it's a great game and some players love it... to death :mrgreen:
Franka
I don't have the patience I did as a kid though. I can't try the same bloody level over and over until I get it right (or start the game from scratch if I run out of lives). I mean, back then I could play Aztec Challenge over and over and over just to get to the fricking pyramid, and that was just level 1 (admittedly, that was the hardest level).



It's different with (most) roguelikes though, they're designed with limited progression in mind, so dying is part of the design. Same thing with Souls games, but I cheated in those. ;)
Taleweaver
The Wonderful 101, on 101% Hard difficulty. Ugh. THAT's a game for masochists alright.
DX5536
Touhou man...just touhou xD Getting reap while listen to great musics
Alex81
Games for masochists?



Jack's games on Nightmare settings :p



(Seasons of the Wolf was -extremely- hard, but still fair and rewarding)



As for Darkest Dungeon? It's fantastic, the music, the mood, the -dark- feel of it all is truly masterfully done.

I can't imagine I've seen gothic horror done better. (Got this kindof Warhammer Fantasy feel over it all)
pahldus
Well I am a fan of most of those Rogue-lites, Darkest Dungeon, Sunless Sea, etc. Have them and your games on my Steam account. One set is for challenging myself the other when I just want good stories, though Sunless Sea has a really great setting, the story gets old quickly as lots of it repeats on itself.



I also love the really long epic RPGs like Witcher and Dragon Age and even other genres. Guess I am a sampler like player. Thing is I like individual games more than a specific genre or even setting. Guess I am just an odd duck is all.
Pace675
You all forget about Lorean MMOs.....nothing but a grind fest....XD
jack1974
Lol reviving this thread, since today played a bit that Mordheim game (I got it in this month Humble's monthly). I was very enthusiast about it until the first battle. In practice with a hit chance >60% you regularly miss 99% of the attacks. It's hard to explain but differently from XCOM2 (which still has that HORRIBLE hit/miss thing) this one seems like the AI really cheats.



Hit/miss chances should be banned in RPGs and combat systems FOREVER!!! I really don't understand the benefit, beside ruining the game experience. Couldn't those top AAA companies learn from super small indies like me? Just use a tiered system which it's already 1000 times better!



Instead of:

70% => full damage

30% => miss/0 damage



Simply do:

70% => full damage

25% => 25% damage

5% => half damage (or whatever balancing requires)



simple, no? no more ragequitting! :mrgreen: