I guess you could do, old characters cannot be romanced unless you pick them for being romanced from the first game, that would eliminate some writing since there'd only be a need to write continuations for the old characters.
I think that's what we're deciding to do. I'm glad I spoke up about this when I did, so we could sort this out. So if you want to "fall in love" with any of the old romance options, they're available in the other game.
jack1974Aug 13, 2012
Times like this, I'm glad all I have to do is sit back and buy the games
Heh, definitely! But no we don't want to repeat the same romances in the sequel, that's what Aleema was talking about. Can't have the same scenes (even with different texts) both in 1st and 2nd game. So the romance would be possible only with ONE character each playthrough (the one you choose at the beginning). This approach has his own problem though: it would mean that to romance all the previous characters, you would have to begin the game several times, one for each, so... not sure it's a good solution either.
I think will first have the artist draw the romances with new characters to take time while I still think about it
jack1974Aug 13, 2012
I guess you could do, old characters cannot be romanced unless you pick them for being romanced from the first game, that would eliminate some writing since there'd only be a need to write continuations for the old characters.
I think that's what we're deciding to do. I'm glad I spoke up about this when I did, so we could sort this out. So if you want to "fall in love" with any of the old romance options, they're available in the other game.
Yeah, I'm more and more thinking to just have full NEW roster of characters regarding romance. Probably the best solution for players and for us too since less headache Old ones could still be present (for variety and gameplay) but not be allowed to romance them anymore
DoctorMario911Aug 13, 2012
Oh i see what you guys are talking about... Man im a slow poke. Just to make sure, are you guys saying that you dont want to repeat the love endings with that character u romanced with in the first one?
If im right then im just wondering if i continue my relationship without messing with the ending if that possible. Like that custom intro you said earlier.
wildcardAug 13, 2012
This approach has his own problem though: it would mean that to romance all the previous characters, you would have to begin the game several times, one for each, so... not sure it's a good solution either.
... So? *has played Loren from start to end 7+ times*
You are not supposed to cheat anyway!
XD
Personally I wouldn't mind that.
If you want to continue the relationship of 'old' you can only date this one character.
If you want something 'new' you play without picking a romance from the first game and can go for someone else.
I do hope thought in the sequel there will be character quests from the start, so you can get to know the new guys better without having to romance them.
Also I'd find it weird if you played Elenor and had Rei's ending and then would pick him out just to break up with him and go for someone else given their romance ending...
SylrissaAug 13, 2012
This approach has his own problem though: it would mean that to romance all the previous characters, you would have to begin the game several times, one for each, so... not sure it's a good solution either.
... So? *has played Loren from start to end 7+ times*
You are not supposed to cheat anyway!
XD
Personally I wouldn't mind that.
If you want to continue the relationship of 'old' you can only date this one character.
If you want something 'new' you play without picking a romance from the first game and can go for someone else.
I do hope thought in the sequel there will be character quests from the start, so you can get to know the new guys better without having to romance them.
Also I'd find it weird if you played Elenor and had Rei's ending and then would pick him out just to break up with him and go for someone else given their romance ending...
I'm in the same boat, I tend to play these types of games over and over again anyways, any with romance options really. Be it your games Jack, or AAA's like Mass effect, as I don't want my characters to cheat on their LI.
but maybe i'm in the minority for enjoying that?
NightsnowAug 13, 2012
This approach has his own problem though: it would mean that to romance all the previous characters, you would have to begin the game several times, one for each, so... not sure it's a good solution either.
... So? *has played Loren from start to end 7+ times*
You are not supposed to cheat anyway!
XD
Personally I wouldn't mind that.
If you want to continue the relationship of 'old' you can only date this one character.
If you want something 'new' you play without picking a romance from the first game and can go for someone else.
I do hope thought in the sequel there will be character quests from the start, so you can get to know the new guys better without having to romance them.
Also I'd find it weird if you played Elenor and had Rei's ending and then would pick him out just to break up with him and go for someone else given their romance ending...
I'm in the same boat, I tend to play these types of games over and over again anyways, any with romance options really. Be it your games Jack, or AAA's like Mass effect, as I don't want my characters to cheat on their LI.
but maybe i'm in the minority for enjoying that?
I cannot believe I made an account just to say something to this... Eh... hi
Anyway, I don't think that you can make a solution that does not have a weakness and I'll third the other two posters above me and say 'So what?'.
Have some reason to start over is not necessarily a bad thing, besides if it is also made in ren'py (which I of course don't know) skip + and easy option will make replaying the game fast enough that it doesn't become a core.
I really think the option of picking one romance in the start as the only option for continouing the old romances are the best. It is certainly better than the you have broken up and now start over solution, because that solution is a bit akward.
jack1974Aug 13, 2012
Oh i see what you guys are talking about... Man im a slow poke. Just to make sure, are you guys saying that you dont want to repeat the love endings with that character u romanced with in the first one?
No not the endings, but the beginning of romance. I mean for example the whole Myrth courting by Saren. It would be pointless (and boring) to repeat that in the sequel IF the player doesn't choose to continue her romance. Each old character would get a new development of their relationship and a new final image (so you can see more of Rei's features maybe this time he'll be more careful where he exposes his assets! lol)
Cool though that lots of people won't mind to start the game several times to play all the romances worse case I guess I could put a cheat mode to change it later in the game...
I think will adopt this system then. I checked and I kept Amukiki, Rei, Myrth & Draco of the first game, while Loren for plot reasons won't be romanceable (at least this is the current idea, anything can still change) and neither Mesphit / Chambara but could come later.
My new idea would be to do that for the sequel, and then if everything goes well I was thinking to do an expansion but that continues the story (but not a full game) so in that expansion could add those 3 characters (Loren / Mesphit / Chambara). As excuse for not being able to romance them in the main game, is that they are all far away for a reason or another so the player can't live the story with them. Then, they come back and player can choose what to do. Hmm is going to be a headache anyway
Also I'd find it weird if you played Elenor and had Rei's ending and then would pick him out just to break up with him and go for someone else given their romance ending...
Don't worry, us evil writers can always add a very dramatic event that will force the player to pick a stance, allowing him/her to break up with anyone!
DoctorMario911Aug 13, 2012
Hmm im wrong yet again ... But i dont get one thing. I dont aee why we cant just continue the relationship from the first one. Not earning hearts again. We just see them do what normal couples do. But your the writer sooo u knows what best for the game
josipa24Aug 13, 2012
So, if I understood this correctly...You can continue a romance with 'old' characters in the sequel, but you can't start a new one wih them. And if you do choose to continue the old romance at the beginning of the game, you can still break up with your lover later and start a new romance with a new character, right?
I actually really like this idea, except for this part...
I checked and I kept Amukiki, Rei, Myrth & Draco of the first game, while Loren for plot reasons won't be romanceable (at least this is the current idea, anything can still change) and neither Mesphit / Chambara but could come later.
This would mean no continuing GxG at all. Karen dies, and Loren and Chambara are away for the duration
jack1974Aug 13, 2012
Well no Karen doesn't necessarily die But you're right, there should be some balancing between the kind of romances you can continue in the sequel. Hmm more brainstorming to do.. arghh
Clark SoulburnAug 13, 2012
I don't want to ruin the fun but if I'm not mistaken a more dire question - at least to me - wasn't asked yet.
How will the sequel deal with the fact that either Loren, Karen or the main character (be it Saren or Elenor) did die? Dependent on Player choice! And I sure would hate it if they would return from their chosen death! For it would render the sacrifice meaningless.
jack1974Aug 13, 2012
Just wait until the expansion is out and that question will be answered
josipa24Aug 13, 2012
I don't want to ruin the fun but if I'm not mistaken a more dire question - at least to me - wasn't asked yet.
How will the sequel deal with the fact that either Loren, Karen or the main character (be it Saren or Elenor) did die? Dependent on Player choice! And I sure would hate it if they would return from their chosen death! For it would render the sacrifice meaningless.
And here's where I apparently missunderstood. I could swear I read somewhere that
Karen would be the canon sacrifice.
Edit: Oh, and btw Jack, is the expansion still coming out on the 15th?
DoctorMario911Aug 13, 2012
I dont get what canon means. I see people use that word alot
ArgleBargleAug 13, 2012
Canon when it comes to media is "What actually happened". It comes up a lot in video games where there are different choices, outcomes, and endings the player can pick. Sequels to those games usually don't have the time and money (or often the desire) to code and write a game that takes into account everything the player could do in the previous game, so they pick certain outcomes to be what they want to work with and base it off that.
For example, in the Knights of the Old Republic game, the player could be male or female, lightside or darkside. In the sequel, KOTOR 2, the player again has those options. After that though, it was decided that for all future games and media the KOTOR 1 protagonist was a lightside male and the KOTOR 2 protagonist was a lightside female, so now in books and in the star wars MMO you run into those characters.
There's also retcons, which is people going back and saying that something that actually happened (or didn't) now actually didn't happen (or did). Again, Star Wars, newer editions of the movies famously went back and changed a scene where Han shot Greedo into a scene where Greedo shot at Han first but missed, Lucas felt that the original scene made Han into too much of a murder. For the Old Republic games, most of the characters and plot of KOTOR 2 got retconned by Bioware and they killed off the KOTOR 2 player character.
jack1974Aug 13, 2012
Edit: Oh, and btw Jack, is the expansion still coming out on the 15th?
Yes I originally thought to do that. But that was before Aleema said would be OK to write a custom intro for all romances, so... nobody dies in the first game
About the date well there's still some scripting left but I think could be possible. Is really a matter of finishing touches, if I had to give a completion percentage right now is 98-99%
DoctorMario911Aug 13, 2012
Ah that makes more sense. Thank you for explaining it arglebargle.
Sweet i thought the expansion coming out at the end of august but this way better.
Lilly himeAug 13, 2012
Edit: Oh, and btw Jack, is the expansion still coming out on the 15th?
Yes I originally thought to do that. But that was before Aleema said would be OK to write a custom intro for all romances, so... nobody dies in the first game
About the date well there's still some scripting left but I think could be possible. Is really a matter of finishing touches, if I had to give a completion percentage right now is 98-99%
I wanna play it now. *rolls around*
wildcardAug 14, 2012
About the date well there's still some scripting left but I think could be possible. Is really a matter of finishing touches, if I had to give a completion percentage right now is 98-99%