pahldus
Dec 15, 2017
Wow that is one poor bastard!

jack1974
Dec 16, 2017
The values are mostly placeholders

Anyway the map is starting to work, needs some tweaks but seems fine. I am thinking to use a more "open-world" approach, a bit like the first game where you could do different quests at once, and the main plot wouldn't go on until you finished certain ones.
I'll be alternating coding with some writing/planning depending on the mood, and of course if I get news from either Cursed Lands or Love Bites I'll pause to work on them since they have the priority

jack1974
Dec 16, 2017


https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DRKHrFgXcAA4LlF.jpg" style="max-width:100%">
Finished redesigning the quest screen. Lol before was still showing the old textbook from the fantasy GUI, slightly out of place

Don't mind the texts since is just a temporary placeholder... but the question is real!! Rebecca was better with shorter hair, or with the new long hair? this is a crucial problem for the future of Planet Stronghold!

Troyen
Dec 16, 2017
Hey, are we going to be starting at level 1 again? I know importing level data from PS1 would lead to all kind of balancing nightmares, but maybe you can "fake" part of it by having us start at level 5-8 or something and just tune everything around that and adjust exp and exp/level appropriately.
jack1974
Dec 16, 2017
Importing data from PS1 wouldn't be possible at all since we use a completely different system here

I'll see if makes sense to give a starting boost, considering I'm planning to allow up to level 50, gaining a few levels in the beginning shouldn't be a problem in this game. But it's a minor detail since in practice in all RPG (even AAA ones) you always start back to level 1

Anyway for this game shouldn't be a problem.
Troyen
Dec 16, 2017
Well, technically the Mass Effect series didn't start you at level 1. Even though the combat system changed between 2 and 3, you kept your level and began with some skill points if you played the previous game. But then the game was tuned that the majority of your level skills were earned from playing the current game.
That's where I got the idea. It's a little weird to always reset to 1 instead of something reflecting how the characters grew from the previous game's experience. Even if the difference is just cosmetic (like you start at 10 and level to 60, but the number of skill points you get in the end is roughly the same, because you adjusted the base values downward and changed the combat system so nobody would notice).
jack1974
Dec 16, 2017
Yes I understand what you mean. I still have to decide how skills will work to be honest

But starting at a higher level and tweak the progression as consequence should be good.
Jaeger
Dec 16, 2017
I don't think starting at a higher level is necessary unless you designed character levels and progression in such a way that starting at the bottom is very rough. I think levels are a reflection of a character's experience during the course of their current adventure, not necessarily what they had prior to that.
jack1974
Dec 17, 2017
Well it seems the vast majority of people agrees with you:
https://twitter.com/pcmacgames/status/942016022688731142
only 15% said that's not OK to start back to level 1, while the others are OK or indifferent
In this case it could also be explained by plot reasons - several years have passed since the events of the first game, and the various characters had no reason to fight anyone. This could get skills a bit rusty. Anyway, I think I'm going to start to level 1 but quickly gain a few levels, since there are 50 levels and in this game I'd like to have level up occurring more often.
Franka
Dec 17, 2017
You could just have more skills already unlocked at level 1, to say that these people aren't total greenhorns.
jack1974
Dec 17, 2017
Yes that's how it will work based on your class choice/other characters predefined classes. I'm still messing around with skills and while I'm not planning a skill system like previous game (where you could have each category up to 100!) for sure I'll have 10 levels each skill, like Pistols 1,2,3 etc giving damage bonus and such.
Jaeger
Dec 17, 2017
Is there a reason why you upped the level cap to 50? In PS1, I didn't have any characters going above 16 by the end of the game. Higher level caps is not a necessary a negative, but I'm just curious about the design choice.
jack1974
Dec 17, 2017
No particular reason, in the other games with this engine the limit was 35, and in SOTW you would reach around level 30 towards end of the game, but a few people reached the level cap of 35. In this case I wanted to have level up come more often, since I think assigning points/skills is a part of the fun. But maybe I'm wrong

In any case the level cap is 50 but it won't be necessarily the required/late game level, not at all. I will code the game as I go and then see what level I reach towards end of the story.
pahldus
Dec 17, 2017
As long as each level up feels significant then more is fine, but if there are going to be superfluous levels, then less is better.
jack1974
Dec 18, 2017
The idea is that there are several weapons categories: Pistol, SMG, MG, Rifle, Assault Rifle, Sniper Rifle, Heavy, Psionic and armors LightArmor, MediumArmor, HeavyArmor. Each one with 10 levels of "proficiency" which lets you wear different quality and give bonuses, for example in progression you can use Fine weapons, then Mastework, then Rare and lastly Legendary. There's also level restriction of course, but also by quality based on the skill.
So based on the above there are 8 weapons + 3 armors = 11 x 10 = 110 points to assign (some classes will have restrictions as already said). If I give 1 skill point on each level, so 50, you can fill half of the skills (but that won't be much noticeable except for the Soldier, the others have less weapons categories in which they can spend their points).
I think in this case 50 levels are justified, but of course it's still a bit too early to say. Need to do some more tests

Jaeger
Dec 18, 2017
You can always give more skill points per level and instead of leveling up more often.
I don't think rifles need to a be in a different category from assault rifles, especially when real assault rifles are capable of switching firing modes as needed.
Honestly, I don't like Psionic amplifers as a weapon category due to be being restricted to one damage type. I think psionics would be better using normal weapons when they are not using their special abilities.
Troyen
Dec 18, 2017
I'd prefer fewer skill points per level if you leveled more often. There's a point that comes in the last half of your games where character progression pretty much grinds to a halt because you need a lot of experience to get to the next level, but you hit a plateau with the exp quests, mobs, and missions award you.
It's less interesting to grind away when your next level is 15 encounters out than it is when you only have to go 6-8. Even when the total skill points is the same.
jack1974
Dec 19, 2017
Haha see the developer's dilemma. Two posts asking the opposite (more skillpoints, less levels vs less skillpoints, more levels) one next to the other

In my previous games indeed you would level up mostly doing quests (which gives more XP compared to grinding) while some players asked for the possibility to get more levels up through grinding. This of course means I need to balance the enemies accordingly (ie in Hard mode you need more level ups while in Easy it's not required).
I'll try to find a compromise between the two.
Regarding Psionic my bad, there ISN'T indeed a psionic weapon. By mistake I copy pasted badly. There's Psionic damage type, but the amplifier are considered helmets (armor pieces) which can be worn only by Psionics.
About Rifle/Assault Rifle I wanted to give another weapon that Scout class could use beside Pistol and Sniper Rifle, but maybe I can remove it. Even in real life though there are rifles who aren't assault rifles, so I don't think it's completely wrong?
Jaeger
Dec 19, 2017
Haha see the developer's dilemma. Two posts asking the opposite (more skillpoints, less levels vs less skillpoints, more levels) one next to the other 
In my previous games indeed you would level up mostly doing quests (which gives more XP compared to grinding) while some players asked for the possibility to get more levels up through grinding. This of course means I need to balance the enemies accordingly (ie in Hard mode you need more level ups while in Easy it's not required).
I'll try to find a compromise between the two.
As long as it's not like Dark Souls (though it was purposely designed that way), where you need a need significant level increases to notice a difference in power, it should be fine.
About Rifle/Assault Rifle I wanted to give another weapon that Scout class could use beside Pistol and Sniper Rifle, but maybe I can remove it. Even in real life though there are rifles who aren't assault rifles, so I don't think it's completely wrong?
That's understandable. It's true there is a dizzying variety rifles out there; and definitions would continually change as weapons and tactics evolve. The question is how are you going to make the distinction between 3 types of rifles for the purposes of your game? Is it a shorter carbine with less in the way of range and firepower, but lighter and easier to handle? Or is it a designated marksmen rifle that falls somewhere between an assault rifle (for general purporses) and a sniper rifle (longer range and precision)?
jack1974
Dec 19, 2017
Each weapon also has a firing mode, so rifles could only do snap/normal/aimed shot, while assault rifles could do also semi/automatic mode (in practice more shots fired in a single turn).