myoksy
Sep 07, 2016
OK will do an update tomorrow with a bit more XP, since I don't think will hurt anyway. Regarding Jana I think I fixed that (I noticed it myself while testing) but will take a look to be sure.
thank you!
As data points: I just loaded older saves to compare XP gains.
Party level 3, encounter with ex merc and 2 dogs
0.8.0 - 85
0.8.9 - 78
Party level 6, encounter with 2 vampire bats and 3 giant bats
0.8.0 - 63
0.8.9 - 54
Party level 10, encounter with 4 headless men
0.8.0 - 136
0.8.9 - 106
Party level 22, encounter with 2 vampire bats and 3 giant bats
0.8.0 - 95
0.8.9 - 65
Party level 26, encounter with vet merc, ex merc, 2 mercs and a dog
0.8.0 - 515
0.8.9 - 332
this is more or less as I recall my current game - until level 4 or so everything felt normal and then the game became sluggish (see pages of my wild theories about the cause in the old beta thread...)
Franka
Sep 07, 2016
more opinions would be extremly welcome, but the few times I asked in my posts no one was willing to chip in.
Sadly, I think I played the earlier beta to death already, and can't focus on playing the game any longer.
But then I'm also the kind of person who tries to break things by playing in unconventional ways, as evidenced by my last game where I finished without entering the catacombs or doing any non-plot robbery missions at all.

myoksy
Sep 07, 2016
as evidenced by my last game where I finished without entering the catacombs or doing any non-plot robbery missions at all. 
when I read your account I laughed out loud. what was it? 8 years of legal life followed by storming the castle with lots of bombs? the sleeper cell you created was near perfect
jack1974
Sep 07, 2016
As data points: I just loaded older saves to compare XP gains.
Thanks I got also your email, and will try to see if I can make the same XP as the older version, if you think that one was well balanced

The issue as I thought was with the "XP scaling by level" thing.
myoksy
Sep 07, 2016
a slightly larger divisor would probably fine, somewhere around 20 to 25 or so without the complex formula you used in environment.rpy. the pre-0.8.1 endgame was slightly too XP rich - the last catacomb level pushed the party from 24 to high in the 25 area, and the party was missing about 10 to 20 thousand gold.
this led to level 26/27 before the last story dungeon can be bought, so a tad above the recommended level.
jack1974
Sep 07, 2016
Yes I'm going to try that, wanted to simplify stuff

jack1974
Sep 08, 2016
Did the update with the XP tweak, I put 25 in the formula, since 20 was a bit too much XP in my opinion. 25 should be OK I think

myoksy
Sep 08, 2016
The result of your change will be seen when of the the beta testers reaches mid game in a fresh play-through. I'll try to find some time.
jack1974
Sep 08, 2016
Thanks

Today have to attend a funeral (nobody really close luckily) so probably won't be able to test anything

myoksy
Sep 08, 2016
Diseased: Tool tip does not show the HP amount, only the percentage. Both values would be better, similar to Frozen et al.
About the XP rewards: I started a new game and played it until party level of 4 (merchants until the forced catacomb visit, as I needed only 20 XP more to reach lvl 4 after successfully clearing the first catacomb level one additional merchant at the end) and persuaded QoT* to give me an overview of old and new XP outputs for every encounter.
[code]
avg enemy level;new XP;old XP;
1;11;14;
2;15;21;
2;27;36;
2;11;15;
3;28;38;
1;21;26;
2;19;23;
1;11;14;
2;11;15;
2;7;10;
1;7;9;
1;11;14;
1;7;9;
1;26;32;
2;11;15;
2;29;40;
8;17;32;
5;21;35;
7;29;55;
7;21;38;
8;27;53;
3;32;48;
4;19;30;
7;25;48;
2;18;22;
[/code]
(should be usable as CSV to create colourful charts with excel)
The most important result is the rather significant difference for higher enemy levels (last handful of lines in the catacombs with encounter levels of 7 and 8 are currently my best examples) so I fear the game will again become sluggish without a fast and rewarding advancement. but this is only a prognosis, I'll have to feel and see mid- and end-game before I can give a better feedback.
eta
A few more XP gains, this time including the second catacomb dungeon. With the current system experience will be halved around level 12
[code]
avg level;new XP;old XP;
3;27;38;
4;29;43;
2;55;74;
4;32;47;
6;45;75;
6;46;79;
8;38;74;
12;49;110;
11;44;106;
3;59;88;
[/code]
* and saw that you still have debug output on the console not caught by non-developer installs: character.rpy in getItemSkills() and getValue() : P
jack1974
Sep 08, 2016
Sorry, as always it's late so might have not understood completely: you are saying that it's still not as much XP as the "original" 0.8.0 ?
I'll find those debug output that escaped my axe

myoksy
Sep 08, 2016
We knew beforehand that your new formula results in lower XP gains : ) But now it's possible to estimate the rate - the highest enemy level I saw (12, in the second dungeon of the catacombs) gives about half the XP in 0.9.0 compared to the calculation used in 0.8.0.
As I said before: I don't know if advancing will feel slow reaching mid-game and actually _playing_ the game. But I am not very confident, mostly because the pacing was imo excellent until party level 20 or so in a game with normal difficulty.
I will report back when I played the current game longer.
myoksy
Sep 09, 2016
you are saying that it's still not as much XP as the "original" 0.8.0 ?
just realized that my XP prediction was wrong - incorrect order of calculations : ) so it will not be as drastic as I feared (50 % less experience around lvl 12) but still a notable difference between 0.8.0 and the current 0.9.0.
but those are technicalities and it's probably more helpful to discuss a more basic topic: I am not sure why the XP gains should generally lower. the only explanation I can think of is that you believe the game is too short (or this was reported outside of the forum). to present an opposite view: imo the length is fine, something like 20 hours per play-through (ballpark estimate) and replayability is high (four times to see all romance combinations).
only the last phase before end game was a little bit too abrupt as a result of the accelerated XP gain with high-level enemies, but this can be solved without slowing down the earlier chapters. e.g. a cut-off for typical enemies in the last chapter before the climax: int(self.cExp+(self.cExp* min([self.level, 21])/15)) - without the complex XP formula you formerly used in environment still a tad lower than before ; )
myoksy
Sep 09, 2016
a more optical thingy: PC had a hit chance of 78%, the enemy dodged the attack and the log line reads "..., damage considerably reduced! (15% melee dodge chance)". shouldn't this read "22% dodge chance"?
jack1974
Sep 09, 2016
No I think the length is fine too. To be honest I didn't had the material time (between various projects and other real-life stuff going on) to retest the game as much as I wanted after the XP change

Looking at your formula, I need to browse python docs to see what min does

But I guess that's a formula that speeds up XP gain after level 21 or so ?
a more optical thingy: PC had a hit chance of 78%, the enemy dodged the attack and the log line reads "..., damage considerably reduced! (15% melee dodge chance)". shouldn't this read "22% dodge chance"?
No because the hit chance depends also on the attackers' stats. The one in the log is the "base" target dodge chance. So in your case if you had a 7% bonus due to critical hit.
Probably is better to remove that value from the log since could be confusing and doesn't really add much (since the final "right" calculation is the one in the damage preview).
myoksy
Sep 09, 2016
But I guess that's a formula that speeds up XP gain after level 21 or so ?
exactly the other way round
min() selects the lowest value of a list. so until an enemy level of 21 the additional gain is <lvl>/15, higher level foes give the same XP as a if they are lvl 21 (to slow down leveling up in the last phase of the game)
as an example: base XP 20
lvl 1: 20 + (20 * 1/15) = 21
lvl 10: 20 + (20 * 10/15) = 33
lvl 20: 20 + (20 * 20/15) = 46
lvl 21: 20 + (20 * 21/15) = 48
lvl 35: 20 + (20 * 21/15) = 48
lvl 666: 20 + (20 * 21/15) = 48
No because the hit chance depends also on the attackers' stats. The one in the log is the "base" target dodge chance. So in your case if you had a 7% bonus due to critical hit.
Probably is better to remove that value from the log since could be confusing and doesn't really add much (since the final "right" calculation is the one in the damage preview).
thanks for the explanation and yes, removing would make sense - the value is not especially informative for mere players
jack1974
Sep 09, 2016
Thanks for the explanation. Now that I think more carefully, some time ago during early beta I lowered the XP needed to level up the latter levels, so that maybe speed up everything.
Anyway I'll just use your formula, no point in doing other tweaks now

I will do another update tomorrow, I also added a few lines in Yenna scene, if you don't pick the "pacifist" option, will explain that you obtain the letters anyway.
myoksy
Sep 09, 2016
some time ago during early beta I lowered the XP needed to level up the latter levels
the old back-and-forth game : D
Anyway I'll just use your formula, no point in doing other tweaks now 
it's effectively your formula used until 0.8.0 with a small tweak
myoksy
Sep 09, 2016
I just tried it with a new normal game (first two catacomb levels, first story dungeon and some mansions)
https://postimg.org/image/3xn9dreat/
the absolute XP values (Y axis) are not that important, it's the difference between the three calculation methods - and the one I proposed is still lower than the old method used until 0.8.0. I don't know if it's that important that the XP gains are mostly unchanged, if this should be wanted instead of "<lvl>/15" something like "<lvl>/11" is probably more exact.
for RL reasons I cannot offer my time as tester this weekend
jack1974
Sep 09, 2016
Maybe this weekend will have some time to test myself, but I think the new system (the one that will go live in the update tomorrow) should be "high enough". I don't think we necessarily need to go back to the old XP though!