Desktop Forums Blog Support Patreon
Official Steam Group | Patreon Chat
Maelora
Apologies if I'm being over-sensitive. But it's an old trope in films and books from a few years ago... Basically, to only include gay characters if they die, or split up, or are otherwise unhappy at the credits. It's still with us, see 'Blue Is The Warmest Colour'. In fact, the movies where the gals ride off into the sunset together are pretty rare: 'DEBS', 'But I'm A Cheerleader', 'Imagine Me & You' being the best)



But I'll add that Jack *ISN'T* doing this at all - Winter Wolves are great in offering an LBGT option, and it's just unfortunate coincidence here that the gay girls get mostly sad endings!



(Incidentally, my first choice for Loren was her mom, and I loved that ending. I went back and did Loren's and it was so bittersweet I cried for hours. Still a very appropriate ending, just so sad... As is Draco's if Saren dies...)
Maelora
Okay, if this is true, I'm so happy I'm gonna buy Max's storyline too and see if Rakesh can make an honest man of him! :)
Sylrissa
Okay, if this is true, I'm so happy I'm gonna buy Max's storyline too and see if Rakesh can make an honest man of him! :)


Haha, sounds good!, you go get him!. I haven't heard anything about the Rakesh endings yet.
Maelora
Thanks, Sylrissa, agree with everything you said.



As regards Mass Effect, as much as I hated that ending, choosing 'Destroy' with full war readiness shows Liara (or Sam) refusing to put Shepard's name on the Normandy memorial, then cutting to her taking a breath in the ruins of London. Not ideal, but it strongly implies she is still alive. But yeah, I think we all wanted to see 'little blue babies'!
Maelora
Okay, if this is true, I'm so happy I'm gonna buy Max's storyline too and see if Rakesh can make an honest man of him! :)


Haha, sounds good!, you go get him!. I haven't heard anything about the Rakesh endings yet.


Haha! Nor me, but he's a very interesting character! I really felt for him, unable to tell his parents he wanted to be an artist, or that he's bisexual. Having a non-stereotyped Indian character shows just how good the writing at WW is.



(and I kinda wish Max x Dominic was on the table as a romance... I think that would have been hilarious!)
Sylrissa
Thanks, Sylrissa, agree with everything you said.



As regards Mass Effect, as much as I hated that ending, choosing 'Destroy' with full war readiness shows Liara (or Sam) refusing to put Shepard's name on the Normandy memorial, then cutting to her taking a breath in the ruins of London. Not ideal, but it strongly implies she is still alive. But yeah, I think we all wanted to see 'little blue babies'!


Thank you so much!, I'm glad someone reads my long ranting replies :oops:



I agree the extended ending DLC for Mass Effect with full readiness and the Destroy ending, did make the ending not ideal but tolerable, while the original launch one was just a utterly disgusting way to end all the build up to the trilogy, had over 100k people in a single poll up in arms over it, so it certainly wasn't a minority.
jack1974
No problems Maelora, I forgot too and I did know about the ending (my official excuse is that was too busy with all the bugs!).

Glad you enjoy the writing! Personally I'm very happy by MrEnvy8 work (lol that nickname) and I'm eager to see the next stuff he'll write (he should do Undead Lily now).

And yes I know how it goes in other games/movies/writing in general, how the gay/lesbian are portrayed. While I don't want to limit the freedom of writers, I'll make sure to suggest at least an alternative (even if hard) ending where things go well :)



As for Rakesh ending: as posted elsewhere, is different from others since you need to help him with his situation with parents. So in his case, you don't get a bonus for the stats sum, but by how you played the storyline and how much you helped him. The score goes from 0 (bad ending) to 12 (happy ending). I can confirm that if you max the help with parents storyline, the Max/Rakesh ending is happy :)
Maelora
Really appreciate, it Jack!



I know you try hard to give us choices and include lots of different types of characters. We all appreciate your efforts!



Good to know the boys get a happy ending! :)
Maelora

I agree the extended ending DLC for Mass Effect with full readiness and the Destroy ending, did make the ending not ideal but tolerable, while the original launch one was just a utterly disgusting way to end all the build up to the trilogy, had over 100k people in a single poll up in arms over it, so it certainly wasn't a minority.


Totally agree. Three games and literally days of playing, and we deserved better. I still can't believe that they did that (though to be fair, everything up until that abomination of an ending is great, and I cried at Anderson's 'You did good, child...' And Shepard's word to Liara just before they are parted are genuinely powerful, Jen Hale's voice is so full of emotion there!)



But Winter Wolves are better than Bioware! :)
Sylrissa

I agree the extended ending DLC for Mass Effect with full readiness and the Destroy ending, did make the ending not ideal but tolerable, while the original launch one was just a utterly disgusting way to end all the build up to the trilogy, had over 100k people in a single poll up in arms over it, so it certainly wasn't a minority.


Totally agree. Three games and literally days of playing, and we deserved better. I still can't believe that they did that (though to be fair, everything up until that abomination of an ending is great, and I cried at Anderson's 'You did good, child...' And Shepard's word to Liara just before they are parted are genuinely powerful, Jen Hale's voice is so full of emotion there!)



But Winter Wolves are better than Bioware! :)


Certainly better then what's become of today's Bioware at any rate!.



And yeah the rest of ME3 apart from the ending was good, Mordin's scene still makes me tear up, he's the best scientist salarian there will ever be!
Maelora
Oh, I saved Mordin :) Luckily, I hate krogan...



Oh, and I got the 'happily ever after' ending for Isabella. Really sweet, reminded me of 'Love and Order', in fact.



The girls finally ride off into the sunset together!



Thanks for this great game, Jack - I'm seriously impressed. Now, off to play as Max...!
j20019

I agree the extended ending DLC for Mass Effect with full readiness and the Destroy ending, did make the ending not ideal but tolerable, while the original launch one was just a utterly disgusting way to end all the build up to the trilogy, had over 100k people in a single poll up in arms over it, so it certainly wasn't a minority.


Totally agree. Three games and literally days of playing, and we deserved better. I still can't believe that they did that (though to be fair, everything up until that abomination of an ending is great, and I cried at Anderson's 'You did good, child...' And Shepard's word to Liara just before they are parted are genuinely powerful, Jen Hale's voice is so full of emotion there!)



But Winter Wolves are better than Bioware! :)


Certainly better then what's become of today's Bioware at any rate!.



And yeah the rest of ME3 apart from the ending was good, Mordin's scene still makes me tear up, he's the best scientist salarian there will ever be!


I've always felt that Bioware lost touch with what made past games good... like interacting with fans and not making 'art' (their excuse for why they did the original ending).



Seriously... can you imagine Loren with the production of Bioware?



...I need to sit down. Too much awesome to think about. :p
Maelora
Put simply, Bioware lost faith in what made their early games good. They abandoned Space Opera for Mass Effect after Drew Karpyshin left, completely changed Dragon Age in tone, visuals and story, and forced a horrible 'canon' on Knights of the Old Republic, invalidating player choices. Then they deliberately declared war on their own fanbase, and didn't like the results.



Pretty much a 101 of how a company shouldn't behave towards its fans.
Miakoda
I do think some of the changes with BioWare can also be attributed to when EA bought them out. I know it gave them greater financial security, but you can trade security for freedom in such cases...and I have a feeling this was a large part of Dragon Age 2.



But I also see the changes (like with EA) as a problem with the greater games industry. There is a lot of money to be made if they can hit the right demographic...but this also leads to a sameness of product.



And it doesn't help that many players do expect top graphics, etc...which sends budgets sky-high. Of course, a lot of companies are to blame for this as well. They tout this feature and that, and then complain how much it costs.
MrEnvy8

Well, you didn't even say WHO you played as!!! :lol: there are some happy, some sad and some bittersweet endings, depending on who you play as.


Anne/Isabella. Yeah, I know she's an amoral floozy who was always likely to get bored and dump you, but it's frustrating that you can't get a happy ending for a gay character, because your only choice for a lesbian character is an unreliable maneater...


You can get a happily ever-after ending with Isabella...



Edit:



Okay, I see you've found it now. Awesome. I thought there was a bug, I was going to be upset. I really didn't want to make the gay relationships bittersweet. But there is an element of naïveté to Anne that I wanted to acknowledge with that ending.



Glad you found it! :)



Edit2:



Okay, now that I'm done freaking out that the good ending is broken for Isabella, I've read the thread... Last thing I'll say Rakesh definitely has a happy ending and that Jack's mostly right, it depends on you helping him out with his parent situation. The walkthrough in the beta thread gives tips on it. Rakesh actually has the most endings because of the variable interactions :) (Though I reused some text).
ValHallen

Well, you didn't even say WHO you played as!!! :lol: there are some happy, some sad and some bittersweet endings, depending on who you play as.


Anne/Isabella. Yeah, I know she's an amoral floozy who was always likely to get bored and dump you, but it's frustrating that you can't get a happy ending for a gay character, because your only choice for a lesbian character is an unreliable maneater...


You can get a happily ever-after ending with Isabella...



Edit:



Okay, I see you've found it now. Awesome. I thought there was a bug, I was going to be upset. I really didn't want to make the gay relationships bittersweet. But there is an element of naïveté to Anne that I wanted to acknowledge with that ending.



Glad you found it! :)



Edit2:



Okay, now that I'm done freaking out that the good ending is broken for Isabella, I've read the thread... Last thing I'll say Rakesh definitely has a happy ending and that Jack's mostly right, it depends on you helping him out with his parent situation. The walkthrough in the beta thread gives tips on it. Rakesh actually has the most endings because of the variable interactions :) (Though I reused some text).

But you cant have a happy ending with isabella if you play with max :/
jack1974

But you cant have a happy ending with isabella if you play with max :/

Actually the best ending (600 stats) is not too bad. Ends with:


"Our breakup was amicable, hell we even had a few... rendezvous when she was in-between lovers. She still writes from Mexico from time to time. Actually, her last letter said she was coming up soon, and wanted to get together..."


sort of "open ending", but sounds promising if you ask me! 8)
Miakoda
I do appreciate the fact some of these endings are along the lines of "A few years later..." Nothing wrong with the characters doing some growing up apart either.
Maelora
Got perfect endings with both Anne/Izzy and Max/Rakesh.



Very, very happy with both. Rakesh felt like a 'keeper', and while Izzy seemed like a floozy, it was nice she matured and came around in the end.



Very nice writing, actually... I'm very impressed, thank you!