Desktop Forums Blog Support Patreon
Official Steam Group | Patreon Chat
DunKalar
Maybe it would make sense to have two versions depending if you play as male or female, like I do with my dating sim ?

(still thinking about it and throwing ideas... even if ultimately I'll value mostly Aleema's opinion since she has to write it).


I think this is a better approach than splitting the content in two parts since you can tell the whole story without the need for cliff hangers or the problem of integrating people like Nook or Breza in the second half (which will lead to a hell of a ride in romancing conpared to romances that you prolonged from the first part). And since the urge to create mile stones in the game that flawlessly connect to the next game parts would be gone, your decision/romancing tree is much slender (and thus less writing/coding to do) without people feeling that something is amiss.



And to quote some older post, it is Loren 2, not the Love Boat :-) If you have three parts (Loren 1, Loren 2.1, Loren 2.2) with different romances each, it kinga gets the feeling of a romancing simulation and not an epic rpg ;-).
Aleema
I don't like the idea of Saren vs Elenor for several reasons. Are we supposed to assume that both characters traveled down the exact same path to glory in the original game, both becoming second-in-command to Loren? And if not, how do we decide who is the "real" Player Character? Will we erase history from both of them, start them over as simple slaves again? And if we're really going to suspend disbelief that they both are the Player's Character, they start with the same obstacles and they travel down a very similar plotline, why are we putting them in two different games? I've always assumed Saren and Elenor were the same possible identity. It's cute to think if you chose one, the other is still out there, but how do we actually account for that? Do we have to write two totally different approaches to the game, one if you're second-in-command to Loren and the other if you're a recently freed slave? (Because I'm sure the way they would operate would be vastly different, not to mention their relationships with the old party members.)



What I'm saying is that it opens up a can of worms.



However, I do see the appeal in having two different protagonists for two different games, to prevent the clean restart and romance problem. It would save us a bunch of headaches. But perhaps that second protagonist could be someone other than Saren or Elenor ...
jack1974
The problem is that as you know, there are already all the romance CGs done, so doesn't matter for this problem. I mean, after Loren 2 we can stop using Elenor/Saren (I'd be happy to avoid all this previous romances thing). But still the original problem of this thread stands. Anyway, maybe the solution is to just do like the previous game, and maybe have different DLC with new main plot and new characters to romance :)

The mess with the previous game was because there were characters that could join/die (Mesphit) and influence the endings (Zeal/Morte/etc). But if each DLC is a separate new main quest from the storyline, that wouldn't be a problem at all.
DunKalar
Yea I know what you mean. It is the same problem BioWare has with Dragon Age Inguisition where they have to tie up ends that just do not fit together logically.



Nevertheless, I think there will be many disappointed players if you shift appreciated consorts into the second half of the game and let them wait another year. And I don't think that it will be a logical problem to split the game into gender dependend games. It is clear that Saren / Elenor are the same entity. But I doubt that there will be great holes in the plot. Most of your players already finished Loren 1 and know the story told by the game. You can do a small intro like "the following story assums that the hero saren/the heroine elenor helped Loren to defeat fost and rose to glory from a past as slave to the amazon princess." and then the story around saren/elenor (who ever you chose) starts. Don't think this is a great problem. And I bet your customers will appreeciate this solution more than transfering companions from the first game to the second half of the game.





Another solution might be, that you include Saren / Elenor as a minor NPC who helped in the military but did never shine as the other "personality" for some reasons. Or you add them into the party like in SOTW but that might just twist the line like Aleema said.
josipa24
I don't know, I kinda always thought that Saren/Elenor existed in alternate universes or sth and they were both the 'real pc', they just couldn't share the same space, if that makes sense.



So I also like the idea of splitting the game based on gender. To be honest, it's mostly because it would suit my tastes and playstyle and I could just get my lady protagonist and Gx romances without buying another PC I'd never use. But also, I don't really see the problem with suspension of disbelief over Saren's/Elenor's probable similar journey in this case - they have already had a really similar plotline in the first game. The story felt different and was altered because of your actions - choosing how you interacted with the characters, they way your companions talked to you sometimes, the order in which you did your quests when possible etc. That was enough for me.
Anima_
I can think of two additional alternatives.

The first is to simply take several romances out of the game but leave the hooks for them in the script. That way they can be added in an Add On or as DLC. Not sure how much this would actually reduce the workload.



The second is to separate the romances into two parts as well. It wouldn't reduce the number of romances but their volume. So you would continue a romance from the first chapter in the second.



Not sure how much either would help, but I do think that making it a single game would be very risky.



The framework wouldn't need that much additional work either way, just like Aleema already said.
jack1974

The second is to separate the romances into two parts as well. It wouldn't reduce the number of romances but their volume. So you would continue a romance from the first chapter in the second.

The problem with this is that people would expect a romance CG, but if the romances continues in the second part, then we'd need two romance CGs :o Since there are already tons (more than every other game I've ever made) that is not possible.



I emailed Aleema an idea (which has spoilers so I cannot post here). But in practice the player still plays as Saren/Elenor, but there are two parallel storylines, and the player must choose which group of people to join. They would happen in the same time, but in different places. This solves the problem that "second game should take place after first game events". They happen at same time, and player can play as Elenor/Saren and decide to play the first story (which would involve Jul) or the second story (which would involve Loren). And since they happen in parallel, there's not anymore the problem of "yes but why in the second game you can't continue/break romance with Mr/Ms XZY!?" :)
P_Tigras
I'm speaking only for myself here. Jack may see it as going from 16 to 12, but I see it as going from 2 to 1, as there are only two characters, one new, one old, in part 1 (Chamby, Jul) whose romances interest me, and now I'm hearing that one of them must go. This is highly disappointing to me. I thus have a decided preference for Anima_'s proposed alternatives. And if you absolutely have to remove somone, and don't intend to add them back into part 1 later, than please remove someone other than Chamby or Jul.
ValHallen
I'm speaking only for myself here. Jack may see it as going from 16 to 12, but I see it as going from 2 to 1, as there are only two characters in part 1 (Chamby, Jul) whose romances interest me, and now I'm hearing that one of them must go. This is highly disappointing to me. I thus have a decided preference for Anima_'s proposed alternatives.

I feel the same, Chamby and Loren are my favorite from the first game and Jul is the only new interesting character to me. So my hype for the game is very low noe...

And with 24 romance, I fear the second game will have the same problem that the first game had, If you dont romance the character you dont get to know them well. So I dont see why i should get the first game
P_Tigras
Jul being romancable in the 2nd game feels better pacing-wise. Having her go from villain to lover is a difficult transition and shouldn't be rushed. At least, that's my opinion. Feel free to convince me otherwise!


I fully expect the transition for the Jul romance to be difficult, nevertheless the groundwork for the romance still needs to be set up in part 1. Succubi are expert at using their sexuality to gain what they want, and I'd be highly surprised if Jul didn't try to use her sexuality in an attempt to gain her freedom, food, and/or slaves from Day 1. How the protagonist deals with her flirtations and her attempts to gain control by inflaming lust will do a lot to set up the tenor of their romance. Usually, feelings come before sex. With Jul on the other hand things needn't follow the usual order, although the sex would likely be safer if they did. But who says the player has to play it safe? Living dangerously can be a lot more fun, especially if you're cunning or tough enough to survive... And who says that she can't stay tied up while they do it? :twisted:



Should you decide to move a bi female, than I strongly suggest Selith instead. She's something of an experiment with no established fan base. The smaller the cast of romance interests, the more important it is to include characters that have the widest possible appeal. And Jul not only has an existing fan base, but she'd also motivate more impulse buys than Selith with her scaly green skin.
jack1974
Well the problem is that I'm sure whatever character I move, an user will complain. If I move Amukiki, tomorrow I'll see messages of someone "oh no". And so on :lol:

About Selith, the idea was to keep a fair amount of old/new characters, also in the first part for plot reasons there should be enough new characters (though this part could even be changed if really must). So makes more sense to move two old characters in the second part so is more balanced.

As always, making everyone happy with the romances is the most difficult part of the game development (and not doing the RPG itself)!

Anima idea could maybe work only if we do it this way: for the old romances, assuming they continue from previous game, you'd get the romance CG in the first part. For the new ones, you would get to know them in the first part but get the CG romances in the second part (doing 12 new images + variants is totally not possible).



Anyway, will speak with Aleema and decide, based on what she is more comfortable, since ultimately the game story must be cool and don't want to put too many restraints. The feedback was still useful since got some ideas :)
DunKalar
Yea, but your players will talk mostly about the romances ;-D



Chamby needs to be in the first part :P
Nighteye
They're both good, with a slight preference for option A. I don't want to wait too long for all the new characters.
Svanhildr
I'm fine with Anima's idea. I don't want the new romances to go too fast, I want to know them and get the feeling like time passes so they also learn about eachother before even considering rolling in the hay so to speak.
Makoto Naegi
Given the options, I'd choose option A. But here's my issue: let's say I play this game for the romance options, and I want to romance character X, who was in the first game and will be in the first sequel batch. Now, I'd like to play the second batch too, but what motivation do I have if I can't romance the character I want too? I'd like my character to have... well, not necessarily a happily ever after, but at least some closure to their relationship at the end of it all, rather than the second batch treating it like the previous romance didn't count/exist. In this respect, I'd honestly say that I'd rather have one large game that costs $50 so I could get the entire story, rather than 2 games at $25 each when I only feel encouraged to buy one of those games.
jack1974
Haha thanks, I must admit is somewhat reassuring, in this moment of "this game at $1 is too expensive!" to read so many encouraging posts (it also puts a LOT OF PRESSURE, but that's the other side of the medal).

Aleema and I are still brainstorming, probably the best would be to have all the old romances in one game, and all the new ones in another. Since it seems clear to me that there's a lot of people that want to continue/see the old characters (makes sense), and another group that is looking forward to play with "the new guys" (they don't necessarily don't care about the old, but are curious also about the new ones).

I think though that for now we'll just start the game and make it so it CAN be splitted in two, and then we'll see how it goes since is hard to make long-term previsions. To say the truth, a reason I wanted to split in two is because I might need to release a new game sooner for financial reasons (depending though how other games and business in general goes next year) rather than wait 1 year (or 18 months maybe...) and release a huge big game.



Thanks for the feedback everyone, was very interesting for me to read. And I must say I'm very lucky to have a bunch of awesome people like you motivating me every day in my indie journey :wink:
P_Tigras
Well...of all the old romances, my favorite was Loren, and Chamby was runner-up. So after hearing that I'd unfortunately have to wait until part 2 to see Loren again, I was looking forward to at least seeing Chamby in part 1. On the question of old vs new romances, that matters to me less than whether or not I find them interesting. Of the two romances that caught my interest in part 1, one was old (Chamby), and the other was new (Jul).



Whether the CG's for the new romances are in part 1 or part 2 matters less to me than that the relationships develop seemlessly though both parts. I'm fine with the CG's for the new relationships being placed in part 2, but I don't want to feel that there are sudden changes in personality as the new characters become romanceable in part 2, or, for that matter, that the old relationships are forgotten about and allowed to languish in part 2. Regardless of where the CG's are placed, opportunities to develop the relationships should exist in both parts of the game, at least for characters present in both.
jack1974
As I said, we're still thinking about it, and I think we can start writing the beginning of the story so maybe we get some inspiration... however, I might be reconsidering Anima suggestion: while I can't do twice the CG amount, I remembered that I was thinking to do some pin-ups. So I could just have a pin-up image/event in the first game, and the final romance in the second! Doing a pin-up image is cheaper and faster, since only features the character and not all the various combo with Elenor/Saren. So in practice I wouldn't need 24 new CG but "only" 16 extra CG (one for each character excluding Elenor/Saren), which might be possible :)
P_Tigras
As I said, we're still thinking about it, and I think we can start writing the beginning of the story so maybe we get some inspiration... however, I might be reconsidering Anima suggestion: while I can't do twice the CG amount, I remembered that I was thinking to do some pin-ups. So I could just have a pin-up image/event in the first game, and the final romance in the second! Doing a pin-up image is cheaper and faster, since only features the character and not all the various combo with Elenor/Saren. So in practice I wouldn't need 24 new CG but "only" 16 extra CG (one for each character excluding Elenor/Saren), which might be possible :)


Sounds good to me. :)
DunKalar
Awwww :-( I wanted my life-size Chamby Pin-Up as a special :-P



I still think that there will be complaints how ever you will decide unless you make one big game (which I would also buy) or you divide all romances into two independent parts, so that you can "finish" your romance with your favourite npc in the "first" part of the game. Otherwhise you will have to include a long intro for the second part to satisfy all the custumers who just do not want the first part because Chamby is missing ;-). And imagine all the bragging of chamby's and amukiki's fan army, if they are not romancable in one of these parts ;-).



I suggest that you include all romances in both parts (if you want to split the game) but prepare something like a waypoint for all of them, which will be a conclusion to the romance somehow but can be resumed in the second half. This gives you the oportunity to tell a long romantic story, without the old .... how did you call it .... "omg I just met you, please take me here hard" :-P .... from the first game. Otherwhise you have to write short but hellish rides of a story for the new charakters and find a good solution why the players should not romance someone else out of frustration while they wait for their hero(in)es to reappear in part two ;-).



Just my two cent.



I know it is a pain in the ass to write such a story ;-) If the Yuri writer from Nicole is good, maybe he can support some routes?