Troyen
Aug 24, 2018
I feel stuff like that is usually a given since even when a game's story is all "you must race here to defend the kingdom urgently or all will be lost!" there's always still time to do every side mission, level your crafting skills, collect all the fish, etc. It's nice not having every mechanic explicitly explained with a help screen (especially with an easily accessible save button), but I've also seen your forums long enough to know some people will complain if it's missing. -_-
jack1974
Aug 25, 2018
Yes, I've learned that is better to give MORE info than less. Especially when it's about deadlines or some "potentially game over" stuff. Even if in this case it will be hard (maybe some "time critical quests" later in the game, but just that).


https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DlZnwE_WsAABeJA.jpg" style="max-width:100%">
meanwhile added the good old colony barracks, but differently from the first game, you won't find any special items there. You can craft some good stuff once you gather materials but by default the items offered in the armory will be normal/common items, just enough to get you started

jack1974
Aug 28, 2018


https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DlsxY3oWwAAtgE0.jpg" style="max-width:100%">
the random encounters are finally working, still need to tweak them but they show up properly on the map

There are so many because I'm testing, in the final game there won't be 20 random encounters on each map!!

jack1974
Sep 02, 2018


https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DmE_SpvWwAATfup.jpg" style="max-width:100%">
more coding on random encounters, now when you "stumble" on one of them (or your ship goes there on purpose for the grinders out there

) you can choose if to engage or avoid. Avoid gives HP/Morale penalty, while engage obviously starts the battle.
Differently from PS1 I am thinking to not have the random encounter be "deadly battles", since even if you lose, your party will have so few HP that probably they need to go back to the colony to rest and "waste" one day of in-game.
So for now I'm going to keep it this way, changing it in any case won't be a big deal (maybe I'll do that only in Hard/Nightmare mode).
My goal is to have a moderately challenging game in Normal (like Cursed Lands) but that is also very punishing in Hard/Nightmare (something that wasn't possible in Cursed Lands due to the game structure).
jack1974
Sep 04, 2018


https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DmPdbsoX0AA1LN2.jpg" style="max-width:100%">
I think I have the right idea about implementing the crafting in this game: during your exploration you’ll find “datapads” that contains blueprint to craft weapons/armors of different rarity (you’ll also need the right materials).
Of course you'll also still find items while looting enemies after a combat.
Now need to code the actual crafting screen, but it will be very simple, not like Amber

jack1974
Sep 06, 2018


https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DmXay1TWsAEtJSZ.jpg" style="max-width:100%">
started with the easiest thing, the upgrade process. I am simply thinking to allow legendary weapon to be upgraded/increase level. Probably will just be the increased damage or armor defense, since allowing to change the other stats could make this too powerful and searching/looting for a better item almost useless

Troyen
Sep 06, 2018
That's...a lot of different resources for a side-game. I think it's fine to upgrade legendary weapons, as you're still needing to gather the appropriate materials to progress. If balancing is an issue there could be a specific crafting material needed for legendary upgrades that only drops from fixed, set points in the game.
Also, can you change it to "
The party got a new item!"?

jack1974
Sep 06, 2018
That's...a lot of different resources for a side-game. I think it's fine to upgrade legendary weapons, as you're still needing to gather the appropriate materials to progress. If balancing is an issue there could be a specific crafting material needed for legendary upgrades that only drops from fixed, set points in the game.
Yes but after a while will be very clear what each one is for. What I meant was that for a moment I had the idea to offer single upgrades, like "upgrade damage" or "upgrade weapon speed" etc. But if people can craft the perfect custom weapon would be too easy.
Also, can you change it to "The party got a new item!"? 
Yep

jack1974
Sep 10, 2018


https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DmsBUPAXcAEayHE.jpg" style="max-width:100%">
finished the "upgrade item" part. You can either use common materials or gharl stones. Gharl stones are much harder to find (if you wander around and do all the encounters probably you'll still get enough since I'd like people to upgrade their items, but still not as common as the others). The others more common materials in this case is always metal+depends on weapon damage type, for example explosive attack=needs radioactive materials, acid weapon=toxic material and so on.
I'll do something similar for armors

This week I plan to finish coding this screen completely, unless more ballbreaks happen (hopefully not lol). Last week wasted 3 days for totally stupid stuff (one HD broke, so I decided to get a NAS to avoid future issues like this).
jack1974
Sep 14, 2018
Since was stuck in past days for non-dev related thing I got some time to rethink the "non-combat skills".
The original effects won't work well, now that I have a half-working crafting screen I noticed they were a bit pointless. 2% of reduction of resources needed for crafting, etc. The values were too low to have an impact. And if I raised them, they could be too strong. In short wasn't working.
So I am going to change the name, from "non-combat skills" to "generic skills" or maybe "shared skills".
Each character has their own unique skill tree (4 unique skills + 4 class-based skills) and then this other set which is the same for ALL characters, so probably "shared skills" works.
They will still provide an extra bonus beside the skillchecks, and I am going to make it combat-related as well.
For example each skill point spent on Science will increase Energy damage +1, every skill point on Survival will increase healing/HPregen by 1 and so on. (in this game there are bigger numbers so +1HP regen is not a big thing).
They will keep a bonus beside the skill check but a bonus that has an immediate effect, since the crafting part could even be entirely optional (you won't NEED to use it to win the game) so it's better if they provide a bonus to something that the player will have to do - the combats (unless you play in VN mode obviously!).
jack1974
Sep 17, 2018


https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DnSwEWLW4AEchDR.jpg" style="max-width:100%">
added salvaging to the crafting menu. It's a bit silly to be doing this from scratch after I had it done in Amber but sadly the two framework weren't compatible

jack1974
Sep 21, 2018


https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DnnQ_sCXgAA5nl6.jpg" style="max-width:100%">
finished the tutorial and also tweaked a bit the words used to determine the items quality. Main reason is actually a bit funny: "Masterwork" was definitely too long to display it on many istances (like in inventory) so I needed to find shorter words!
The last thing left from this screen is the upgrade part, I need to tweak it since values are completely wrong. After that I can finally move on! (I never expected this part to take so long).
Troyen
Sep 21, 2018
I'm going to nitpick the categories here:
- Quality. While technically fine "these are quality ingredients", it's also the name of the category, and especially in games it's often used as a category label. I'm not sure if this'll cause confusion, or if people will be able to easily rank "Quality" compared to "Fine" or "Rare". I would suggest "Good" but I also don't know how to compare "Good" vs "Fine" ("Good" might be slightly better).
- Excellent. From your picture you seem to rate this between "Quality" and "Rare", when "Excellent" would imply it's at the top end of the scale - perhaps next to "Legendary".
However, the bigger issue is some games use rarity to indicate value (more rare = higher value), some games use quality to indicate value (masterwork, Fine, normal, junk, excellent, etc.), but you're kind of mixing the two. These are orthogonal concepts, it's difficult to think about them on the same scale. When I get an "Rare" item, how do I know it's more valuable than an "Excellent" item? Just because you find a rare pokemon doesn't mean it's going to have good stats.
The only label that's an exception to this is "Legendary" because it can fit with both scales, and players know from other games that Legendaries are usually the best there is.
jack1974
Sep 22, 2018
OK so let's see: Common, Uncommon, Fine and Legendary are OK

I am not sure which words could use in the middle. Hearthstone for example is not really clear either, you have "Epic" cards and "Legendary". I wouldn't necessarily assume Legendary is better than Epic, if I didn't knew already from the game.
I'd like to keep Rare since I used it already on all my other RPGs (SOTW, Cursed Lands, QoT) so previous players already know that Rare is just before Legendary. Or I could change it into "Epic" keeping same colors.
The main issue then is Quality/Excellent and which words to use instead... I need to check other games and see how they do it!
Franka
Sep 22, 2018
Maybe there are simply too many tiers?
jack1974
Sep 22, 2018
Yes I was thinking about that too. Each one gives more point to stats (so that a same level item between Common and Rare has a difference) but maybe I could cut at least one tier, maybe two. Need to do some experiments

Troyen
Sep 22, 2018
I think "Epic" is more common in video games these days than "Fine". It's the terminology used in everything from RPGs to lootboxes (Overwatch and Heroes have them). I've seen it in God of War and several other non-Blizzard games as well.
But that's in the US market. I don't know if the international market uses other terms. (Well, I know some JRPGs do, but they use their own custom system.)
And within the game you can use visual tricks to indicate something clearly better. To go back to your Hearthstone example, when you get a legendary item the voice announcer goes crazy and screams "LEGENDARY" and there's all kinds of visual explosions and stuff. That's much more dramatic than getting an Epic item. You don't need a voice announcer here, but you could perhaps style the border or something so that the best tiers are more visually appealing and stand out compared to the others. Kind of like how gold cards were all shiny and fancy in PSCD compared to bronze.
jack1974
Sep 23, 2018
Thanks for the feedback. Yes I could use something to highlight the higher tiers, though not sure about borders since the GUI is already very crowded (as you can see from the screenshots). But when the player gets the item, yes (since Legendary will probably require quests to be obtained).
jack1974
Sep 25, 2018


https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Dn7wQbtXUAA3V-9.jpg" style="max-width:100%">
I’m almost done (finally! lol) with this screen. I removed one quality tier and also allow each datapad to craft unlimited amounts of that item blueprint (if you have enough resources of course). This way decrypting one gives more reward to the player. I think that even if this could be used to take advantage, since the item's level is determined when you decrypt it, there's also some strategy involved.
If it's a Rare/Epic item you can always upgrade it later, but even in this case requires resources. So in the end it should be more or less balanced

The tiers now are: Common, Uncommon, Quality, Rare, Epic, Legendary. Works much better

jack1974
Sep 26, 2018


https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DoAmVB4X0AAsnFU.jpg" style="max-width:100%">
today discovered that adding crafting to a RPG is a major pain in the ass
Jokes apart, I randomly stumbled while testing on an interesting side-effect: if you equip an item to a higher level than the character who is currently equipping it, you effectively make that item unusable!

Epic fail haha. So I disabled that possibility and added also some more tutorial texts.
Lol I wonder if this week I'll finally finish this part, I can't wait to be done with it!