At the beginning I thought I wouldn't like Kurt, but he really grew on me to fight for first place.
Darren I felt a real connection with early on. Not sure if this is really a spoiler, but
Ted was nice, but I don't like being yelled at or told what to do. Even though I knew he was a good guy and Nicole handled it so well, the yelling thing got to me. Now, his dad Ron on the other hand....
Jeff... well. Jeff was interesting. I actually liked how Jeff acted at the end of the last normal scene and the beginning of the special scene, when he meets her out of her final.
No matter my favorite, all the stories were great fun to play!