Yes that's what I'm thinking of doing now. There should be always the chance to win, even if you don't have high seduction skill, but would require you to always pick the best choice out of 3 (or maybe 4, so the % of getting the right one are even lower).
In the case above, depending on how high is your seduction skill, you could still win maybe selecting only 70% of best choices, and so on.
It will be a pain to write, but should be fun to play. Also, luckily this is only for the "boss fights"
Thanks for the "brainstorming help"!